Atlas Data Privacy Corp. v. The Lifetime Value Co. LLC
Sent back to state court Nov 20, 2024D. New Jersey · 1:24-cv-04850 · Removed to federal court April 11, 2024 · Remanded November 20, 2024
- Statute
New Jersey Daniel's Law
- Defendants
The Lifetime Value Co. LLC; BeenVerified, Inc.; BeenVerified, LLC; NeighborWho LLC; The NumberGuru, LLC; PeopleLooker LLC; PeopleSmart LLC; Ownerly, LLC
- State case
Superior Court, Mercer County · MER-L-000272-24
- Federal judge
Harvey Bartle III
Atlas Data Privacy Corporation filed this suit in the Superior Court in Mercer County on February 7, 2024, under Daniel's Law, which lets New Jersey judges, prosecutors, police officers and their families require a site to stop publishing their home address and unlisted phone number. Atlas sued as assignee for roughly 19,400 covered people who, it says, asked the LTVCO sites to stop showing their details and were still listed ten business days later. The NumberGuru, LLC was a defendant from the first complaint.
The defendants moved the case to federal court on April 11, 2024. Judge Harvey Bartle III sent it back on November 20, 2024, in one order that returned 39 Atlas suits to the state courts, the cases against Spokeo and Whitepages among them. That ruling was about jurisdiction and didn't touch the merits. The LTVCO defendants asked the Third Circuit for permission to appeal, with The NumberGuru, LLC among the petitioners, and were turned down on March 18, 2025.
Atlas still counted it among 111 pending state cases in November 2025, when it asked New Jersey's Supreme Court to put them before a single judge, and the defendants' lawyers listed it as pending in a January 2026 letter opposing that request. The court said no on May 1, 2026, so the case stays in Mercer County. We haven't found a public record of a ruling or settlement since.





















