Atlas Data Privacy Corp. v. The Lifetime Value Co. LLC
Sent back to state court Nov 20, 2024D. New Jersey · 1:24-cv-04850 · Removed to federal court April 11, 2024 · Remanded November 20, 2024
- Statute
New Jersey Daniel's Law
- Defendants
The Lifetime Value Co. LLC; BeenVerified, Inc.; BeenVerified, LLC; NeighborWho LLC; The NumberGuru, LLC; PeopleLooker LLC; PeopleSmart LLC; Ownerly, LLC
- State case
Superior Court, Mercer County · MER-L-000272-24
- Federal judge
Harvey Bartle III
Ownerly's product is names attached to home addresses, which is exactly what Daniel's Law lets New Jersey judges, prosecutors, police officers and their families have taken down, along with unlisted phone numbers. Atlas Data Privacy Corporation sued the LTVCO companies under it in Mercer County on February 7, 2024, as assignee for roughly 19,400 covered people, and Ownerly, LLC was a defendant from the start.
The companies moved the case to federal court in April 2024. On November 20, 2024 that court granted the plaintiffs' motion to send it back, as it did for 38 other Atlas suits the same day, because it found it had no jurisdiction over them. Ownerly, LLC was among the defendants who asked the Third Circuit for leave to appeal, and the answer on March 18, 2025 was no.
The case was still pending in Mercer County in November 2025, when Atlas listed it among 111 state cases it wanted handled together, and in January 2026, when the defendants' lawyers opposed that plan. New Jersey's Supreme Court turned the plan down on May 1, 2026. We haven't seen a public record of how the case has gone since.





















