FTC / DOJ v. TruthFinder, Instant Checkmate & The Control Group
Enforcement actionU.S. District Court, S.D. Cal. · Stipulated order announced Sept 11, 2023 · FCRA + FTC Act
- Civil penalty
$5.8 million
- Defendants
TruthFinder · Instant Checkmate · The Control Group Media · Intelicare Direct · PubRec
- Core allegation
Operated as consumer reporting agencies despite disclaimers
- Commission vote
3-0
The FTC alleged the companies assembled and sold background reports marketed for employment and tenant screening (making them consumer reporting agencies regardless of their disclaimers) without ensuring maximum possible accuracy, without checking permissible purpose, and without investigating disputes. The complaint also alleged that push notifications and marketing emails claimed subjects had criminal or arrest records when the record was sometimes a traffic ticket; that "the MOST ACCURATE information" was claimed with no verification steps behind it; that a "Remove" button only hid information from that one customer's own view; that "Flag as Inaccurate" triggered no investigation; and that customers got free premium reports for posting HighYa reviews without the required disclosure. The stipulated order imposes a comprehensive FCRA monitoring program, permanently prohibits FCRA violations when operating as a CRA, bars accuracy misrepresentations, and requires endorser monitoring. The press release notes sibling Instant Checkmate was already under a 2014 FTC order for similar conduct.




















