Atlas Data Privacy Corp. v. Scalable Commerce LLC
ActiveD.N.J. 1:24-cv-04160 · Third Circuit No. 25-1564 · Filed 2024
- Statute
New Jersey Daniel's Law
- Co-appellant
National Data Analytics, LLC (publicdatacheck.com)
- Covered persons
~19,000 (judges, prosecutors, law enforcement)
- Status
Certified question argued at the N.J. Supreme Court · decision pending
Atlas Data Privacy, as assignee of roughly 19,000 covered persons, sued 100+ data brokers for publishing protected home addresses. Scalable Commerce and National Data Analytics appealed together after the district court upheld the law in November 2024; the Third Circuit consolidated the appeals, heard argument in July 2025, and certified the key liability-standard question - what mental state Daniel's Law requires - to the New Jersey Supreme Court, which accepted it in October 2025 as A-8-25 and heard argument on March 17, 2026. A decision is pending.

















