Atlas Data Privacy Corp. v. Scalable Commerce LLC
ActiveDocket checked August 4, 2026.
D.N.J. 1:24-cv-04160 · Third Circuit No. 25-1564 · Filed 2024
- Statute
New Jersey Daniel's Law
- Co-appellant
National Data Analytics, LLC (publicdatacheck.com)
- Covered persons
~19,000 (judges, prosecutors, law enforcement)
- Status
Certified question argued at the N.J. Supreme Court
Atlas Data Privacy, as assignee of roughly 19,000 covered persons, sued 100+ data brokers in 2024, alleging they kept publishing covered persons' addresses after takedown notices. Scalable Commerce and National Data Analytics appealed together after the district court upheld the law in November 2024; the Third Circuit consolidated the appeals, heard argument in July 2025, and certified the key liability-standard question (what mental state Daniel's Law requires) to the New Jersey Supreme Court, which accepted it in October 2025 as A-8-25 and heard argument on March 17, 2026.


















