Google’s Cookie Policy Raises Concerns

Brandon McCauley
Brandon McCauley
November 26th, 2021
google-cookie

Within the last two years, Google had announced that it was going to eliminate third-party cookies from the company’s own browser, Chrome. While the initial plan was to have this done by 2022, the tech giant ultimately delayed the project’s deadline towards the end of 2022 just a few months ago. Most recently, however, Google has also been under investigation with a regulatory agency from the United Kingdom.

Some Context

At first glance, Google removing all third-party cookies from their Chrome browser seems like a wonderful idea.

As we at Redact have covered before, cookies are essentially used to track a user’s preferences and often tailor advertisements to them. Regardless of whether the impact cookies have on each user’s privacy is concerning or not, the public generally still errs toward the side of protecting their privacy whenever possible. With this in mind, it is no surprise that Google’s announcement would be positively received.

Upon further reflection, however, there may be some underlying factors driving the tech giant’s drastic decision.

The Investigation Begins

While Google is confident about their new policy by arguing that it would increase each user’s privacy by preventing their history from being collected by advertisers, not everyone is entirely on board.

Earlier this year, the United Kingdom’s Competitions and Markets Authority (CMA) announced that it would conduct an investigation of Google’s bold move. The reason for this investigation is based on the suspicion that Google may using an underhanded method to enrich itself at the expense of its competitors.

The CMA’s chief executive, Andrea Coscelli noted that they found the new policy would “potentially have a very significant impact on publishers like newspapers, and the digital advertising market.” Among this, Coscelli also added that there are also “privacy concerns to consider” for this policy.

The Investigation Now

During the months following the CMA’s probing of Google, the multi-billion-dollar enterprise made quite a few compromises and modifications to its original plan. Such commitments included Google:

  • Being more transparent and engaging with the industry
  • Adding that certain functionalities are not removed before third-party cookies
  • Improving the provisions on Google self-preferencing its advertisements
  • Increasing the moderating of Google’s compliance with these rules